Resentments - Sunday evening coming down
Like nearly all significant events that contributed to making and defining Austin's music community, the Resentments were unintended.
The original idea was just a cool deal on Sunday nights, a casual little musical get-together on the one night nobody was working. The rules were simple: no rehearsals, ever. As long as two players showed up, it was an official gig.
The idea was born five years ago, when Joe Ables, the owner of the semi-legendary South Austin music joint known as the Saxon Pub, was strategizing how to bring in a few warm bodies on the deadest night of the week. Somewhere along the way, Ables consulted Stephen Bruton, the guitarist, singer, composer, producer and Fort Worth cat with the Kristofferson/Raitt/Dylan pedigree, who lived a couple miles farther south just off South Lamar and had adopted the club as a home base.
Bruton had developed something of an affection for the room. It had all the basic necessities -- a horseshoe bar, sixteen tables, three booths, a low, postage-stamp-sized stage in the corner where the big-screen TV usually is -- and was far enough off the beaten path, yet close enough to home.
"Saxon Pub is the most unhip place to play," Bruton says. "But the first time I went in, I fell in love with the place when this guy materialized through the haze of cigarette smoke and with this raspy voice, quoted from 'Too Many Memories' [a song from Bruton's 1993 album What It Is], telling me I nailed the third verse."
An early-evening Sunday show would give him a forum to test new songs, let others try theirs out, and play lots of acoustic guitar, something he hadn't done with much regularity since his early days with Kris Kristofferson. Since Bruton had inherited the Doug Sahm chair as Local Wise Man Who's Been There and Done That and didn't mind sharing his experiences with his youngers, he quickly rounded up a quorum of like-minded old-school writers and players.
The initial crew included well-known country singer Hal Ketchum, who also happened to be a frustrated drummer, on drums; Keith Carper, a veteran Austin bassist; David Holt, a gifted and notorious hotshot hired-gun guitarist; and Jon Dee Graham, an equally gifted and notorious guitarist who was becoming better known as a singer-songwriter with a gravel-road growl and a growing list of impressive solo albums.
Bruton picked the name the Resentments. "Geoff Muldaur's daughter in New York had a band called the Resentments. I thought it was such a great name, what better way to honor it than to steal it?" he reasoned.
Over the course of the next year, everyone except Bruton and Graham dropped out because of work demands, other gigs, or relocating. Their shoes were more than ably filled.
Mambo John Treanor came first. His musical roots in Austin were planted deepest, going back to his gig as freeform percussionist for Beto y los Fairlanes, whose weekly gigs at Liberty Lunch in the late 1970s set the stage for the making of a scene. Treanor was an Austin original, a devotee of the city's famous Barton Springs swimming hole who fashioned hats out of roadkill, served time for growing pot, and played with just about everyone in town at one time or another (notably the Vanguards, Jazzmanian Devil, Marcia Ball, Abra Moore, Guy Forsyth and 47 Times Its Own Weight).
Next came Scrappy Jud Newcomb, the guitarist, singer-songwriter and producer (Beaver Nelson) who wears his undisputed championship belt as the Most Insatiable Gig Dawg in Austin with pride. Bruton entered Scrappy's radar as producer of two albums by Loose Diamonds, the band that was Newcomb's calling-card into the Austin scene. They hit it off. Scrappy is Bruton twenty years younger, with a spare, muscular picking style and a curiosity for and appreciation of obscure traditional folk and blues as much as mainstream rock 'n' roll, plus movie-star good looks.
Last to sign on was Bruce Hughes, the utility bass player who rode into prominence with the stridently eclectic Poi Dog Pondering (who around 1990 were Austin's best-selling recording band), played and recorded with practically everybody, and knew Bruton from Lonelyland, one of two bands Hughes plays in that is fronted by Bob Schneider (who over the past five years has sold more CDs locally than any single Austin artist, including Willie).
Somewhere over the following couple years, between getting comfortable with one another, playing weekly rounds of songwriter show-and-tell, trying on a number of offbeat, oddball covers pulled out of the attic, and trading licks, the three guitarists, one bassist, and multidimensional percussionist gelled into a real band. Treanor's death from cancer in 2001 sealed the deal, giving the Resentments motivation to continue and take it to the next level. Somewhere along the way, the casual gig has become something else.
You could describe the Resentments as an Austin-scale version of the Mike Bloomfield/Al Kooper/Steve Stills Supersession group hatched in the late '60s, four decades later -- a reason for three guitarists from varying backgrounds to get together, play, and show what they know.
But I sure won't. To compare them to that diminishes the breadth and scope these guys cover. The bassist brings songs to the table too, and they're pushed by an exceptional drummer, John Chipman, who used to set up Mambo's kit and managed to replace the drummer who couldn't be replaced, the guy who gave this weekly gathering meaning and purpose.
They sure didn't hype it. Everyone has enough work to sustain their chosen career paths as musicians, thank you, and digs what they do for a living. Still, comparisons to everyone from Crosby, Stills & Nash to the Traveling Wilburys, the Texas Tornados, the official and unofficial versions of the Outlaws, and The Band can be justified. There's more to this weekly little off-night get-together than meets the eye.
It starts with the genuine, authentic feel of the songs -- collectively, this quintet carries more songwriters than any other collaborative venture in town. In this setup, their roles as sidemen are as crucial as their composing skills. Throwing a song into the ring every three or four turns that can stand up to the ones your compatriots are throwing in, and then reverting to backup role, is as hard as, if not harder than, fronting your own band for the night.
Once they get comfy on their stools, they demonstrate an exceptional grasp of the songwriting craft, a deep well of musical knowledge, and a mastery of the tricky ability to ply the tools of their trade in a listening environment and still manage to scorch the paint off any empty stools every now and then. It all wraps up neatly by 10 p.m., usually capped with a nice little firepower drill by the three-guitar volunteer army, Graham embellishing the demonstration with searing shots of lap steel ricocheting around the room.
"People come up to me all the time and say this reminds them of Austin before there was a scene," Bruton told me.
I know I can trace the off-night tradition as far back as 1971, when Freda & the Firedogs, the group fronted by Marcia Ball that is regarded as the first bunch of longhairs in Austin who could play authentic country, held forth at the Split Rail, a no-cover joint on South Lamar that would draw spillover crowds on Sunday nights.
It's endured over the years in others forms and fashions: Blue Mondays with Storm at the One Knite, the Tuesday Night Cobra Club at Soap Creek, Tuesdays at Liberty Lunch with Beto y los Fairlanes, Blue Mondays with the Fabulous Thunderbirds at the Rome Inn, Tex Thomas' Sunday night services at Hut's, the Scabs at Antone's on Tuesdays, Toni Price's Tuesday early-evening Hippie Hours at the Continental. None, however, started quite so accidentally or blew up into something so substantial that it created a band, a real band.
I was already familiar with a lot of the Resentments' individual histories. I've known Bruton since high school in Fort Worth. I actually worked with Graham when I was band manager of the True Believers, the mid-1980s rock band in which Graham, a border rat from Quemado down by the Rio Grande, played a crucial role. The True Believers' road manager and sound technician, Mike Stewart, went on to manage and produce Poi Dog Pondering, the studiously eclectic ensemble where master of quirk Bruce Hughes fit right in; his local credentials went back to bands such as Iomega and the Shades from Raul's Club punk era. The True Believers convinced a band from Ohio called the Highwaymen to move to Austin, where Troy Campbell met an eager local boy named Jud Newcomb and conspired to form Loose Diamonds. Newcomb, known locally simply as Scrappy Jud, also worked with Mambo John Treanor in Toni Price's band. And you couldn't claim to be a regular on the club circuit without Mambo having entered your life sooner or later.
But I didn't understand how or why this informal group had blown up into either a) the best band in Austin, b) the coolest regular party in town, c) the best bar band in America (according to MSNBC.com's John Schulian), or d) the Texas version of the Buena Vista Social Club.
So I paid them all a visit.
I tracked down Bruton, who at 55 is the elder of the band, to the studio/rehearsal hall/music museum behind his house, where he tried to explain it in terms we both understood. "You're from Fort Worth," he told me. "You know what it was like. You could do anything, like go from a fiddle convention with David Ferguson at the Round Up Inn to dirty blues at Mabel's Eat Shop to going to see King Curtis and Cornell Dupree over in Stop Six and not blink an eye. It was completely natural to me to listen to the Kingston Trio, the Modern Jazz Quartet and Howlin' Wolf back to back. We didn't know any better. No one knew any better. It was making music on music's terms, see what flies."
Bruton left Fort Worth as the banjo flash of the Brazos Valley Ramblers bluegrass band (at one time, he auditioned for and was offered the banjo chair in the Dillards), and as a white-hot blues player who knew his way around the juke joints. He had co-produced, with fellow Fort Worthian T Bone Burnett, the splendidly atmospheric Robert Ealey & the Five Careless Lovers album Live At The New Bluebird Nite Club (Blue Royal) in 1973, still my favorite live performance recording of all time. And he knew more about music than just about anyone because his dad (a former jazz drummer) and mom ran Record Town, a retail shop known around Fort Worth for having the deepest catalogue of jazz, blues and race music in the city.
"You'd be able to quote from things you didn't realize you knew, to cite the guitar solo on the second cut of the Seeds' first album, or that hard sax sound on Ray Charles' albums," Bruton says. "You heard O Brother, Where Art Thou? That came out of Record Town."
That sounds about right.
He'd started working Austin clubs in the early '70s, with his band Little Whisper & the Rumors and with Delbert McClinton, while living in Los Angeles and working as Kristofferson's guitarist. He moved permanently in 1983 after finishing his supporting role in the film A Star Is Born.
"I realized I was making my money on the road," Bruton recalls. "I wanted to be closer to my mother, my father and my brother in Fort Worth. It was easier getting around, because it was fuckin' Texas. I loved L.A. and I still do, but I didn't want to be sitting around thinking about when I was going to be making enough money to get back to Texas."
He didn't go back to his hometown, though. "There was more going on in Austin than in Fort Worth. Musicians seemed to have more drive and ambition. It all kinda added up."
Since settling in, Bruton has built an impressive resume producing albums for Alejandro Escovedo (which earned him full credentials as a Local Hero), Chris Smither and Marcia Ball, while recording several albums of his own.
The Resentments gig was "a natural extension of what I've done for so long in sessions, gigs, playing for people big and small."
I found Jon Dee Graham one chilly mid-morning five blocks from his house, sitting at a table under an awning at Jo's Coffeehouse on South Congress Avenue chain-smoking American Spirits, taking contemplative sips from his latte, his pale blue eyes fixed on the traffic going by. He said he didn't have a clue why the Resentments were happening. He was somewhat preoccupied since he was on his way to a house on Rebel Road where Charlie Sexton was waiting to finish the mix on his fourth solo album, due out later this year on New West.
But Graham, 44, a hardhead for as along as I've known him, let down his armor-plated badass exterior long enough to try and put the Resentments in perspective in a curriculum vitae that includes stretches with Austin's proto-punk power trio the Skunks, several bad new wave bands, the True Believers, Lou Ann Barton, Kelly Willis, John Doe, Michelle Shocked, Simon Bonney, Ryan Hedgecock, and Calvin Russell, as well as producing Kacy Crowley and Steve Wedemeyer.
"As a musician, I've learned never to pass up an opportunity to play onstage, especially a situation where Bruton and I can jab insults back and forth," he says. "And there's some nights onstage with him that I realize at least once he is the best guitar player in America -- it's hard for me to say it, but it's true. So how am I not going to play with these guys?"
It's still a goof and afterthought, he adds, and for exactly those reasons, it works. "Because of the casual nature, it becomes all about the music and the songs. Mambo and Scrappy, the thing they've turned me on to, is that music is sacred. These songs are so good, how am I able to not do it?
"There's no five-year plan. There's no record contract at the end of the rainbow....Fortunately or unfortunately, I don't know which, it's generating interest," Graham continues, citing last year's tour of Europe as a particular point of growth for the band's profile. "The Germans are swapping bootlegs. By the end of the tour we were selling out places.
"We've built and rebuilt the most patient, willing audience possible. They're prone to listen to the songs, even though sometimes we spend more time talking than playing. Everybody is so good, we play for each other. In some ways, it's a serious head-cutting going on. Bruton makes me play outside myself. If Scrappy has a day off, he spends it learning an album like Big Pink. He's this walking catalogue of songs. Bruce will uncork a funk song that I'll play on lap steel. Bruton writes songs that have chords with numbers on them."
Early one Saturday evening, Scrappy Jud Newcomb, the hardest-working Resentment of them all, and who Graham describes as the "sponge" of the band, was holed up in his South Austin apartment, the seven-days-a-week all-night worker without a gig. He wasn't complaining. The rare night off allowed him to indulge in his second-most favorite activity, listening to records, which in this case meant analyzing an obscure ballad by Billy Stewart, whose stuttering interpretation of "Summertime" was a top-40 pop hit back in the '60s.
Tall and strapping, rather than scrawny and scrappy, the 35-year-old tried to point out with some pride that he actually took enough time early in the day to put a coat of paint on one wall of his small kitchen. But the sloppy paint job might not be the best way to demonstrate to others that he has an outside life. In fact, he shouldn't bother. The evidence around him, from the crates brimming with vinyl, CDs, tapes and books that are piled up around his living room, to the glass bottleneck on the coffee table, to the mandolin he cradled and plinked while conversing, suggest he's all about music.
He didn't like talking about his past too much, though he allowed his mother and father's roots were in Mississippi, that he was mentored by Casper Rawls, Rich Brotherton and Champ Hood, and that he's played with the Atlantics soul revue, Loose Diamonds, Walter Tragert, Beaver Nelson, Toni Price, and Ian McLagan.
"I'm kind of superstitious that way," he says. At one point, he couldn't listen to a National Public Radio program on the radio before a show, reasoning the even, measured voices were the antithesis of what he was trying to achieve when he played. Too much mellow would harsh his buzz.
He said he's always been drawn to what he describes as trance music -- Muddy Waters recordings from the 1950s, the Stones' classic work in the '70s around the time of Sticky Fingers, music from Jamaica since it was first made -- music that could create "this tense atmosphere that could change the way the room looked."
The Resentments do that to him, Newcomb says. "A lot of my education is playing every Sunday, having something click and realized by a melodic passage or a chord change. It's everything I imagined a band could be after I saw The Last Waltz, never mind that I later learned from Levon Helm's book that the movie wasn't the way it was. For me, it's like the Knights of the Round Table with the Resentments."
Bruce Hughes opened the door to his brightly painted wood-frame home on a tree-shaded block of East Second Street, a stone's throw from I-35 and Austin's central business district, long enough to hold it open before he headed back into the kitchen, stepping around and over recording equipment scattered about. He was grinding beans for a midday cup of a rare Kona blend coffee from Hawaii. He really didn't need it because he was already chattering away at the speed of light. He just likes the taste.
As the bassist for Bob Schneider projects Lonelyland and the Scabs (and before that the Ugly Americans), Hughes tends to be absent more frequently than any other Resentment, but never so long to be considered a candidate for replacing. "It's better to be too busy than not busy enough," he reasoned.
Slight, curly haired and constantly animated, he was the last piece to the Resentments puzzle, "the fourth corner of the square" as Graham put it. An Austin native music animal if there ever was one, he grew up on the northeast side of the city, started performing at 13, and has never looked back. "I thought every town was like this," he says. "When I first heard 'Smoke On The Water' coming out of a garage, I assumed Deep Purple lived on Corona Street."
His resume includes "everybody for five minutes" from the punk/new-wave scene, a stretch with the punk-funk band Skank, and time with Arthur Brown and Jimmy Carl Black, Dr. John (for two weeks), Cracker (for nine and a half months), and True Believers, in addition to his aforementioned tenure in Poi Dog Pondering.
"Every bandleader has always given me grief -- 'Why aren't you committed?' I am committed," he says. When Hughes, 42, finally got the "black feather we sent him in the mail," as Graham describes it, he thought he was ready. "I had Sundays off, but it was daunting. There was a lot of intensity. The players were high-caliber. But I'm a quick study. Everything about the Resentments was on the fly: no rehearsals, no charts. After a month, I knew all the material. Then I was hooked. It took me a year before I started to bring in songs of my own."
The payoff is "getting to play with the best players in town who play for the sake of the song. I don't want to shred. Being able to get that feeling of being in the right place at the right time in the right universe -- that's what I'm in it for. The feeling comes quick and goes quick."
John Chipman has what would appear to be the toughest role in the band, sitting in Mambo John Treanor's drum chair. "When you heard him playing, he had this unmistakable voice in his playing," Chipman remembers. "You could literally cut his body in half. One half would be swinging and the other half would be playing straight time. The entire band had to follow his groove.
"It's an honor being Mambo's sub," Chipman said on the phone from Houston, where he was visiting future in-laws and shopping for an engagement ring at a gem and mineral show. The 35-year-old San Angelo native with a music degree from the University of Oklahoma (specialty: marimba) moved to Austin in 1993 and started playing a number of $25-a-night pickup gigs while working days for Tommy Robertson of Tommy's Drum Shop. "He taught me enough at his factory that I built my own drum kit," Chipman says.
He eventually racked up road miles with George DeVore and Marcia Ball before taking stock of what he wanted to do. "After Marcia, I didn't pick up sticks for four months," he recalls. "One Saturday night, my phone rang. It was Stephen. I'd gone to Resentments shows over the previous weeks. Mambo used to bring his washboard to George's gigs, and a couple times toward the end, I came to help set up his drums for him. He was too weak. A month after he died, Stephen asked if I'd come out. He'd tried two or three different guys and it wasn't working out.
"I asked Stephen when he wanted to get together. He said, 'Tomorrow night, Saxon Pub. You know the drill, no rehearsal, lots of ridicule. Show up at 7.' I had nothing to hear. No CDs to listen to. I was probably tentative. But you play what you play. Stephen said, 'Don't worry, if we don't like what you're doing, we'll tell you.' That was two years ago last December."
For Chipman, the Resentments are therapy. "Once a week I get to have a three-hour session with these incredible songwriters who are also incredible players. I'm never shocked by what I hear coming off the stage from any one of these guys. We may play the same song a hundred times, but every time, it comes out different."
He knows he'll never fill Treanor's shoes. "It was real tough at first [replacing Mambo]; I was one of his admirers. There will never be another John Treanor. If you sat down and took a tape of him to a professor of percussion pedagogy, they'd say, 'What's going on there?' I had to listen to him for ages and ages to realize that this guy, when he plays time, he'd make certain limbs swing, then do a straight eighth-note pulse with other limbs, perfect timing, but with a pulse that would ebb and flow in synch with the soloist.
"I've never heard anyone do that in that fashion. Most of the time, that would sound choppy. With Mambo it'd just sound smooth. It's insane. I spent hours trying to replicate what he did naturally and finally gave up. The first month or so, I was constantly second-guessing myself: Is this what Mambo would've done? I finally realized, they haven't told me I stunk yet, and I keep coming back."
Treanor's death on August 20, 2001, was the wake-up call. Toward the end, he was tying his arm above the cymbal stand in order to be able to hold it over the drums and play because he was too weak to raise his arm. "I asked him, 'Mambo, why are you doing that?'" Graham recalls. "He said, 'Because if I don't do this, I can't play.' That is the lesson of the whole fuckin' thing, right there."
"He was profound," Bruton agrees. "And not only his drumming. He personified the Resentments attitude."
Graham and Newcomb visited him in the hospital the day before he died. "It was a Sunday," Graham said. " His mom, Lucille, called and said it was pretty bad. Scrappy and I came down later that day. It was obvious Mambo wasn't going to make it. He was passed out when Scrappy said to me, 'Maybe we ought to call the Saxon and say it ain't gonna happen tonight.' Mambo came to life and said, 'Nuh-uh. Go play the gig. I'm not scared.' He made it clear that to not play would be a disservice to him. It's still his chair. Chances are slim he's coming back to claim it, but if he does, it's his gig."
Things have been snowballing ever since. Last year it began with their discovery by Germans on the last day of South By Southwest. "Someone got word of the Resentments on Sunday night," Bruton says. "Not only is it not part of South By Southwest, it's completely under the radar. How obscure can that be? These guys play one gig at one bar on one night of the week. So of course they loved it."
An invitation to tour in the summer followed. Hughes got the wheels spinning, thinking it'd be great to have a new CD to sell overseas (they'd released a live recording, Sunday Night Line-Up, in 2002). He organized the session and the artwork. They booked engineer-producer Stuart Sullivan's Wire Studios, and two days later, they had a self-titled album to sell on the tour. It was picked up by Austin indie Freedom Records for regional distribution last fall, followed by Freedom's nationwide release on February 17.
"We'd be laughing, cutting up like little kids half the time," Newcomb says. "We didn't even know what songs we were doing. Every song was one or two takes, max. Nobody in the band had ever been in a recording situation like that."
The tour took their collaborative efforts to a higher level. Maybe the covers had something to do with it, encompassing Dewey Redman's racy "Gee, Baby, Ain't I Good To You?" and the country spiritual "Long Journey" by Doc Watson's wife, songs that normally would be judged as strange bedfellows. With the Resentments, they were pieces of Americana that went go together hand in glove. "A critic in Germany said we're a lesson in American music," Graham relates. "That all these different styles that didn't seem to have anything to do with each other came together with us."
Since the band returned stateside, the new disc has developed legs. Hughes' joyously loopy, self-referential stream-of-consciousness tune "People Ask Me" has been added to the playlist of influential Austin triple-A radio station KGSR -- not bad for a song he wrote in fifteen minutes before he started laughing. "Fifteen minutes later, I had seven verses," Hughes says. "There is no rhyme scheme." But there sure is a great big sound backing up his words.
Another European tour is set for this summer. Another CD is being talked about. "The beauty of this band is you don't have to write twenty songs every other year to make an album," Bruton said. "With these guys, you can bring in three songs and have a new release on our own little humble situation and go to Europe and sell it."
It has certainly energized Newcomb. "It's becoming more of a prospect," he marveled. "I think everyone woke up to what's right under our noses. This could develop into a really great band, like The Band. If we had to go out all of a sudden for six months, I'd think it'd be the greatest thing that ever happened."
On a Sunday in January when most folks are at home watching pro football playoffs on television, the loyalists drift in until the Saxon is packed by the time 7:30 rolls around.
Bruton hasn't returned from Delbert McClinton's Blues Cruise. No Bonnie Raitt, Ray Wylie Hubbard, James McMurtry, Freddy Powers, or Al Anderson are standing by, eager to sit in (all have done so at various past Resentments gigs, most recently Raitt in early January). While Bruton's absence is noted with acerbic musings about whether he's gambling in the Bahamas, laying low in Key West, or was simply driven crazy by playing the same four chords every night, "with a harmonica thrown in every now and then," as Graham jabbed, it's no less of a band.
"It leave more room for those who do show to show our stuff," Hughes says about nights when colleagues are missing. "They're all mike hogs, you know." It's a nice way of saying there is so much competitiveness that a prospective off-night can be just as sharp and edgy. With Graham hauling out a boatload of lap steel pyrotechnics to keep the proceedings interesting, it is.
Somewhere in the middle of Graham's song "Big Sweet Life", they manage to get to that special place Hughes talked about -- the reason they play. The instruments lock into a groove that choogles, then soars, launched by Chipman's brushes. Five women and one guy respond by jumping up and dancing in the tight empty spaces between the tables in front of the stage, facing the band, urging them on, letting them know it feels all right. The room seems to levitate.
And though their fifth member is somewhere between Florida and Texas, his words ring true surveying the scene: "This is what happens when you let musicians do what they want to do when nobody's looking."
Joe Nick Patoski has been writing about Texas and Texas music for more than 30 years. The author of Selena: Como La Flor and co-author of Stevie Ray Vaughan: Caught In The Crossfire, he is currently working with Eddie Wilson on his Armadillo World Headquarters memoirs, to be published in 2005.