CD Review: Johnny Cash – The Greatest (Columbia/Legacy, 2012)
Hyperbolium
Posted On August 31, 2012
In celebration of Johnny Cash’s 80th birthday, Sony’s Legacy division has released a tributary live show (We Walk the Line) and a quartet of compilations covering his #1 hits, duets, country and gospel songs. The titles are cleverly punctuated (The Greatest: Duets) to suggest these are songs from one of country greatest artists, rather than definitive collections of the named slice of Cash’s catalog. And that’s a good idea, since reducing Cash’s greatest country or gospel songs to collections of fourteen titles is sure to engender argument. Instead, these collections provide a good sample of the riches in Cash’s enormous catalog.
Country Classics
Cash was a musical omnivore who wove his personal tapestry from folk, country, rock and other genres. He was a musical historian who married into the Carter family he’d long-since revered, and a steward of tradition as a living thing, rather than a pedant who always colored inside the historical lines. The selections gathered here are about the songs and performances, rather than the records – only one of which (“Ghost Rider in the Sky”) – was a hit single. To Cash, these songs were warp threads in country music’s tapestry. And though he wrote many of his own country classics, the producers have focused on others’ songs that meant enough to Cash to garner a cover.
“Country Classics” is to be taken in the wide screen that Johnny Cash lived as an artist. The song list here includes foundational folk songs, historical epics, murder ballads, and numerous songs of romantic longing and heartache. The recordings stretch from 1960 covers of Hank Williams (“I’m So Lonesome I Could Die”) and Hank Thompson (“Honky-Tonk Girl”) to a 1984 recording of the Browns’ “The Three Bells.” Much like the titles on Rosanne Cash’s The List, these are songs that country music listeners should know; some famous, some obscure, but each one a piece of the colorful picture Johnny Cash painted with his career.
Duets
This collection pulls together duets from 1962 (“Another Man Done Gone,” with Anita Carter) through 1985 (“Jim, I Wore a Tie Today,” with Willie Nelson), and shows off Cash’s gravitational pull as a partner. Even when singing with strong stylists, Cash draws his partners into his own musical universe, as he does with George Jones on “I Got Stripes.” The equation is reversed as Cash sings withJennings, the latter’s ‘70s sound backing “There Ain’t No Good Chain Gang.” Cash’s tic-tac and Jenning’s phased guitar mix for “I Wish I Was Crazy Again,” and the two meet in the middle with the rolling trail rhythm of 1978’s “The Greatest Cowboy of Them All.”
Friendship (or kinship) is a central theme of Johnny Cash’s best duets. These weren’t marriages of commercial convenience; they were instances of folk music’s most vital conduit. Cash was a singular musical figure, but one who drew widely for both musical inspiration and personal sustenance. Three of his four Top 10’s with June Carter Cash are here, as are duets with Cash’s younger brother Tommy, his musical fellow-traveler Bob Dylan, and fellow outlaws Willie Nelson and Billy Joe Shaver. The selections are drawn from original albums, Cash’s television show, appearances on other artist’s albums and session tracks previously released as bonus cuts. The set includes liner notes from David McGee.
Gospel Songs
Though Johnny Cash had his share of personal demons, he was a man of deep faith, and a regular singer of gospel music. It’s rumored that he moved to the Columbialabel to escape Sam Phillips’ inability to see a market for an entire album of sacred songs, and to record the 1959 album Hymns by Johnny Cash. Cash had recorded songs of faith at Sun (including the first two titles here), and continued to do so at Columbia, sprinkling them throughout his albums and recording purpose-built volumes such as The Holy Land, from which this collection draws Carl Perkins’ “Daddy Sang Bass” and the original “He Turned the Water Into Wine.”
The bulk of these selections are from the late 1950s through the 1960s, with only “Far Side of Banks of Jordan,” a duet with June Carter Cash, reaching into the 1970s. Many of these recordings aren’t really gospel; “gospel and country songs of faith” would be a more accurate title. Cash’s sanctified work from of the 1970s and 1980s can be found on the double-disc Bootleg Vol. IV: The Soul of Truth, but these earlier master recordings are a better musical spin, and provide a fine overview of material scattered across dozens of original singles and albums.
The Number Ones
This set collects titles that topped either the Billboard or Cashbox charts, forgoing several that topped the Canadian country chart without doing so in the U.S. The collection draws a diverse arc from Cash’s stark, reverb-laden Sun productions of the ‘50s to his last #1, “Highwayman,” sung with Waylon Jennings, Willie Nelson and Kris Kristofferson. Most of the titles will be familiar to even casual Cash fans, though a few of the Cashbox hits, “The Way of a Woman in Love,” “What Do I Care” and a duet with Jennings on “”There Ain’t No Good Chain Gang” remain less exposed. Tracks 1-5 are mono, the rest stereo (“A Boy Named Sue” is presented in unbleeped form), and the booklet includes lengthy new liner notes by Anthony DeCurtis.
