Scott Paul and Sarah MacDougal Biscuits and Gravy Reviews
Scott Paul: Paradise http://www.reverbnation.com/scottpaul
I love this album to bits, I feel like I’ve stumbled on someone who has taken all the threads of my life and made fresh sense of them all. As far as I can work out this is all the more remarkable as ‘Paradise’ represents a mid-life fresh start for a man who’s never bothered with the music industry till now. Having discovered how to be happy and content in his Pennsylvania home, he’s also discovered an urge to communicate to the world the possibility that we can find this for ourselves. The title song, ‘Paradise’ tells it all ; using the tag ‘What if…?’ where John Lennon used ‘Imagine…’, this is a far more grounded set of propositions about where we go wrong in life and where we might go right, culminating in the line ‘What if paradise was just a really good day?’. This idea is taken up in ‘Love What I Do’: ‘ I only make a pretty good living/ But I’m living a real good life/ Get up like the sun and have some fun/ It’s the key to making everyday new’. Accept what life gives you and give freely in return, that’s the general idea.
Scott Paul loves playing with words and this comes out best in the political songs, especially ‘Roll With The Punches’, a mini-epic of a story song with a Dylanesque catalogue of characters, a sardonic humour for the trials and tribulations of life and a rolling funk that builds and builds until you’re left floored and need to go back to the beginning to catch all the detail in the words. ‘New World Order’ is a shorter but similarly sharp take on the state of the world and both these songs contain enough short, sharp observations to be the seed material for several dozen political essays.
As if this mature and intelligent songwriting weren’t enough, ‘Paradise’ has a team of musicians and producers (Scott Paul himself and Teri Amico) dedicated to flying the flag for the strand of Americana founded by The Band. Piano, drums and, above all, guitars sound like Robbie, Rick and the boys re-incarnate. Even Scott’s vocals at times have a hint of Levon Helm about them, though it has to be admitted he doesn’t in fact have the strongest of voices. Somehow the production manages to get round this and the words always come through clearly and allows him the space not to have to fight against his band. Whether this album is a ‘grower’ that will achieve the acclaim it deserves I really don’t know, but I urge you to seek it out – it’s great.
John (Biscuits and Gravy) Davy http://flyinshoes.ning.com/profile/JohnDavy
This album comes to us from Vancouver, not previously noted for internationally successful music – Vancouver conjures a significantly different mental image to Seattle, its close neighbour just across the American border. Strange, then, that this music from the shore of the Pacific should be called ‘Across the Atlantic’, but that reflects Ms MacDougall’s split background, her young years having been divided between Sweden and Canada. Something has been made in the press of a Scandinavian folk background to her songs. That’s as maybe; it strikes me that’s just a useful critical/promotional peg to help her stand out from the crowd a bit. In fact there’s not too much that’s obscure or difficult going on here. Mostly it’s a remarkably skilfully performed and produced album that should travel to pretty much anywhere that English is spoken or understood.
At its most upbeat, ‘Across the Atlantic’ has songs that do the Amy MacDonald thing: gloriously energetic, strongly rhythmic, driven along by crisp drumming and with the lyric absolutely at the service of a tuneful bounce that communicates itself instantaneously. ‘Cry Wolf’, for example, has halls full of people dancing, I’m sure, wherever she plays and it certainly has me dancing round the kitchen; however, the energy of the song belies the reflective, slightly anguished, lyric – not that you’d notice as you sing cheerfully along to the chorus. The album divides fairly evenly between these sort of numbers and much slower tunes with the space in them to indulge a bluer, more reflective mood. A couple of times, on ‘I’ve Got Your Back’ and ‘Ramblin’ ‘, this comes off as distinctly Lucinda Williams-ish which is due in no small part to Tim Tweeddale’s steel guitar and dobro playing. It’s also a tribute to the strength of Sarah’s lyric and the emotional intensity of her singing. Her voice is the star instrument here, so strong, warm and authoritative with that folk music warble at times, like Joan Baez or even Buffy St. Marie.
The furthest she gets from a mainstream approach is on ‘Crow’s Lament’ and ”Hundred Dollar Bills’; with their 2/4 time signatures (which does indeed evoke European folk music) and distinctly spooky lyrical references, as if Rennie Sparks had popped in with some ideas for a song or two. Different again is the closing song, ‘Goodbye Julie’ . Very quiet and reflective, the lyric is enigmatically inconsequential; sung in a wistful frame of mind at the end of the relationship, the question is – is this the end? The two people involved are not currently communicating but the feeling persists that neither has quite given up on the other for good. It’s a nicely sophisticated and self-confident note on which to end a hugely impressive debut record.
John (Biscuits and Gravy) Davy http://flyinshoes.ning.com/profile/JohnDavy